When did someone last ask you about a decision before it was made?
On Monday 16 November, we joined a Townsville Chamber of Commerce roundtable with federal Leader of the Opposition, Angus Taylor MP, and Member for Herbert, Phillip Thompson OAM MP. Business owners talked about the changes hitting them right now. Tax on trusts. Visa rules. Insurance. Wages.
The costs were real. But one comment stuck with us more than any number:
“There’s no accountability without consultation.”
The feeling was shared around the room. Owner after owner described decisions that landed on their staff, their business structures, and their succession plans. Decisions that nobody had asked them about first.
At ideation lab, we call that a design problem. And design problems can be fixed.
Consultation usually comes too late
Most consultation happens after decisions are already made. A draft goes out, submissions come in, a few words change, and the policy lands as planned.
That’s true of governments of every colour, and of plenty of organisations too. People can tell. So they stop turning up, or they turn up angry.
There’s a big difference between asking people to react to a decision that’s already been made, and asking them to help shape it. Most of what we call consultation is the first one.
What human-centred design does differently
In human-centred design, the people affected by a decision help make it. At ideation lab we work in three phases.
1. Discovery
Go to where the problem lives. Before anything is written, spend time with the people who carry the problem, and who’ll carry the change. What do they actually do? What does the issue cost them? What have they already tried? What does it look and feel like to walk in their shoes every day?
2. Design
Build options with them, not for them. Test rough ideas early, while changing them is still cheap.
3. Delivery
Pilot small, measure what happens, and fix it before you scale. Then go back and tell people what changed because of them.
What discovery would have caught
Take the room we were in. Owners talked about:
- Restructuring their businesses at a cost of tens of thousands of dollars
- Hiring and growth plans on hold
- Visa holders heading home because they couldn’t plan their future here
None of that is hidden. A few weeks of discovery with small business owners before major changes like these would have surfaced all of it.
You might still make the change. But you’d design the timing, the transition and the support around how businesses actually work. And you’d keep their trust, or even earn it. Once it’s lost, it’s much harder to win back.
One piece of advice for Angus and Phil
Monday’s roundtable was a good start. Credit where it’s due. Hearing from business is step one. If we could offer one piece of advice, it would be this: before your next policy is written, design it with the people who’ll live with it.
That could look like:
- Doing discovery in the regions, not just in Canberra.
- Sit in businesses and communities before policy positions are locked in.
- Bringing business owners, their staff and the community into a process that shapes the options.
- Piloting ideas in one region first (Townsville’s a great place to start).
- Reporting back on what changed because of what people said.
Do that, and people will trust a policy before it’s even announced. Hearing from people is easy. Designing with them takes more effort and time up front. But it’s a lot cheaper than rebuilding trust afterwards.
Thanks to Townsville Chamber CEO Emma Peters for creating the room. Putting decision makers face to face with the people living the impact is where good design starts. More of this, please.
Planning a consultation or engagement project?
We’d love to help you design and implement it.
